15-year-old Amanda Todd from Coquitlam, British Columbia killed herself this week, after several years of terror at the hands of a cyberbully/cyberstalker and merciless, cruel-hearted peer taunting and physical violence at several schools. Now we’re “outraged”, according to an article in the Toronto Star.
Where was our outrage WHILE this was happening? Why weren’t we standing up for and protecting this girl at the early stages of this story? Where were the adults? Where were her peers?
This story is disgracefully similar to the story of Jamie Hubley, a 15-year old gay teen who killed himself in Ottawa last fall, after relentless bullying starting in Grade 7, when peers held him down and stuffed batteries down his throat.
And it’s hair-raisingly similar to the story of Jesse Logan, an 18-year old from Cincinnati, who killed herself in 2009 after a topless photo she sent to her boyfriend was circulated by the boyfriend after their breakup.* Ironically, Jesse’s story was in the news this week, with the announcement of a $150,000 court award to Jesse’s parents to be paid by the Cincinnati school district, for failing to do enough to help and protect her after the picture and the bullying went viral. I wrote about Jesse’s story extensively in Bullying Epidemic: Not Just Child’s Play (p137-143), looking at the failures of the adults and peers around Jesse to keep her safe both before and after she sent the photos.
And to those who say we need stronger anti-bullying or anti-gay bullying or anti-cyberbullying laws, I ask: Does that $150,000 make Jesse’s parents feel better now? Does that repair the damage to Jesse? Does that undo the horror of finding your child hanging in her closet?
We must learn from these tragedies and commit to much stronger efforts to prevent these crises and catch them and shut them down at their earliest appearance. Every 8 year old should see Amanda’s video (embedded below). Think that’s too young? By 10, sometimes younger, kids are sending naked pictures of their body parts to classmates and other kids they barely know as a way of saying “I’d like to get to know you”.
Kids need much more guidance from adults. We must talk to our kids about sexting before they or their friends start doing it. Talk to them specifically about how to make friends with someone they might like romantically. Talk about the risks of sexting. Once you press “send” or flash for the webcam, there is no getting that picture back. It’s out there forever, as Amanda said. And you’re forever dependent on the emotional maturity and self-control of everyone who might have access to that picture not to pass it on. We must coach kids on how to handle the inevitable breakups and heartache with dignity and emotional self-control, keeping our finger off the “send” button.
Think about the effects of adult-led premature- and over-sexualizing kids’ clothing, starting as young as age 4. Look at our recent post on Halloween costumes for girls on the GirlsRespectGroups.com blog. With so much over-emphasis on sex and sexuality, girls (and boys) think that sexuality is the only aspect of their personality that’s important. The words “Juicy” on the butt of a 4 year old are not cute, not funny, and the start of the breadcrumb trail that can lead to something much worse.
We must do a better job keeping kids grounded in respect for self and others. Adults need to demonstrate these skills in our own lives to be credible to kids. As adults, we must show respect to other adults and towards kids, even when we’re angry at them or disappointed by them, or they do things that contribute to their own problems. And we must intervene early when kids bully one another.
By the time another Amanda is making a video (Jesse Logan went on local TV with her voice disguised to talk about it), the damage is done, and it’s frankly almost impossible to prevent a kid determined to commit suicide from following through. The point is to catch them before they ever consider it, to not push them that far. The only solution to bullying is prevention.
We can do better. We must.
* Nov 18, 2013: We’ve recently been contacted by Cynthia Logan, Jesse’s mother, with an update to the story (see Cynthia’s comment below). Cynthia told us that the photo was taken from Jesse’s phone without her knowledge and distributed. This adds yet another dimension to this story, and another cautionary warning for teens (and adults) taking nude selfies, thinking “it’s only on my phone”. Your phone and your privacy may be at risk from something as simple as a “friend” looking through your pictures and hitting “Send to all contacts”.
It’s like dynamite sitting in a box in a dark room, just waiting for a spark, intentional or accidental, to explode into a bad accident. It requires endless emotional self-control by everyone who sees the picture to keep from forwarding it. Forever.
Please don’t put yourself in such a vulnerable situation, even when you see other friends doing it. If you see that one of your friends has taken a nude selfie, use your self-control to resist looking and resist sending it. Pretend that if you clicked “send” or “open”, you would, at the same time, be sending out a nude or vulnerable picture of yourself, to all your contacts. Would that strengthen your self-control? Surrounding yourself with friends, boys and girls, grounded in respect for self and others, goes a long way towards preventing this problem before it starts.
Have empathy for mistakes, when someone inadvertently puts themself in a vulnerable position. Step in to protect them, not take further advantage. When adults become aware that there’s a problem with teen sexting, make sure that parents and schools are brought together to protect the involved kids and to encourage their whole community to step forward in protection. If parents and schools have not spoken about the perils of sexting and teen romance yet, this is where we start. “We’re so sorry this problem has happened with Sara and Sean. We’re going to coach them through this, and we’re all going to learn how to stand up for our friends at a time like this and learn how not to have it happen to you.” Adults must coach kids through the ups and downs of romantic life, including inevitable breakups, a common time for these sexting issues to surface. We must learn to handle the heartache of a break up with the emotional maturity to keep our thumb off the “send” button.
Thank you, Cynthia, for taking the time to update us. We are so sorry for what you’ve been through. And thank you for working so hard to try to make sure this doesn’t happen again. Mistakes, however, will still be made, and we must do a much better job, standing up to protect our friends and children at the earliest stages of these crises.
My daughter Jessica Logan’s story is wrong. I have the police incident report stating the photo was taken from her phone and disseminated. The attorneys refused to use this as evidence. If the school gate keepers told us what was going on,If the bystanders stood up and spoke out, perhaps our children would be alive today. I only had snap shots of what was occurring. I found out much more after we buried my only child. Schools, Parents, Police Resource officers must take this seriously. We are losing too many kids and teenagers to Peer abuse Suicide.
Our lawsuit was a disaster because our attorney would not use the information provided. She chose to use a teenager’s testimony which is what she called my testimony–“Hearsay.”
Thanks so much for updating us, Cynthia. That’s the first time we’ve heard that aspect of the story, that Jessica’s photo was taken from her phone. It adds another troubling dimension to this tragic story. I wrote about Jessica in my book Bullying Epidemic: Not Just Child’s Play, and I couldn’t agree more. There was a failure of many around Jessica, adults and kids who could have stood up and helped her when she desperately needed it. I’m so sorry for what you – and Jesse – went through. Thank you for sharing your wisdom, working towards the goal of not losing any more children and not leaving children to suffer on their own.